Still Life: Contour Shading

This contour shading drawing has an implied line going in a circle shape going from object to object, this image has a focal point the vase which is positioned on the rule of thirds, the area of interest seems like the flowers next to the vase. The image has a balance of shading on the z axis. We can tell the objects were positioned so that there were no kissing objects, there is depth with many of the objects as they are positioned behind other objects.

There is no orphaned objects with how they were positioned. There is form in this image as we can see the 3D objects being projected.
The arrangement of objects showed off the shadows and the positioning of the light source which gave this image highlights this led to seeing nice contrast and cast shadows being projected.

There is little shading cast onto the table, the table doesn't look perfectly round, some of the proportions look off, the angle of the left vase seems a little out of perspective.

Figure

we can see this figure is in a static pose, we can tell the light source is from the left with 

the way the shading is facing, we notice the figure is in the rule of thirds. 

this image has nice proportions but from the knee to the ankle looks squished

he's added some nice details to the shading also showing the highlights

the figure has nice balance holding the pole

we can tell the figure is slightly angled with the direction its facing

this drawing has nice central mass with the pose the figure is doing

This image has the feet chopped off at the bottom which doesn't help the drawing

the elbow to the hand on the right arm looks too short

the drawing doesn't seem to have much foreshortening.